There's a phrase I hear in the Dubai real estate industry that genuinely drives me mad.
"Just give the client what they want."
Sorry, but that's not advice. That's order taking.
I've been working in Dubai real estate since 2014, and over the years, I've told countless clients not to buy properties.
Sometimes that means walking away from a substantial commission.
And I'm absolutely fine with that.
The difference between an estate agent and an adviser
There's nothing particularly difficult about agreeing with someone.
A client tells you they want to buy a particular apartment. You arrange the viewing, tell them how fantastic it is, negotiate the price and collect your commission.
Everyone's happy.
Until they're not.
Because what a client wants and what makes financial sense aren't necessarily the same thing.
If someone comes to me wanting to buy a property, I'm not there simply to validate their decision.
I'm there to challenge it.
Is the purchase price justified? How does it compare with recent transactions? What rental income can realistically be achieved? How much competing stock will be available when the property is completed?
And perhaps most importantly, who's going to buy it from you when you want to sell?
These are the questions I believe a good property adviser should be asking.
Sometimes the best investment is the one you don't make
I remember advising a client against purchasing an off-plan property in Dubai approximately three years ago.
Another agent had presented a projected net rental return of 8%.
I looked at the investment and didn't believe those numbers were realistic.
I advised the client against buying.
They bought it anyway.
Through the other agent. 😂
The building has since been handed over, and based on the information I've subsequently seen, the net rental return appears closer to 4%.
That's approximately half the original projection.
Now, I'm not suggesting the other agent deliberately misled anyone. Rental projections are estimates, and market conditions change.
But this is precisely why assumptions need to be challenged before somebody commits their money.
A projected return isn't a guaranteed return.
And if an investment only makes sense when every optimistic assumption comes true, I think that's a problem.
Why the exit strategy matters
One of the biggest mistakes I see investors make is concentrating entirely on the purchase.
They focus on the developer, the payment plan, the promised rental yield and how attractive the property looks in the brochure.
But I believe you should be thinking about your exit before you even sign the booking form.
What makes your property desirable?
Is there genuine scarcity?
How much competing supply could enter the market?
Will the property appeal to end users, investors or both?
And what happens if you need to sell sooner than expected?
These questions matter just as much as the purchase price.
I've invested my own money too
My wife Alice and I have personally funded, developed and exited three properties in Dubai.
We've experienced the risks, the costs, the decisions and the uncertainty that come with putting your own capital into property.
And I can tell you that when it's your own money on the line, you look at things differently.
You become much more particular about the numbers.
You think carefully about your downside.
And you learn that a beautiful property isn't necessarily a good investment.
That experience influences the advice I give clients today.
My approach is simple
I'm not interested in agreeing with someone simply because there's a commission available.
If I believe a property represents a good opportunity, I'll explain why.
If I think the numbers don't stack up, I'll explain that too.
And if I believe somebody is making a mistake, I'm prepared to tell them.
That doesn't mean I'm always right. Nobody is.
But I believe clients deserve an honest professional opinion, even when it's not the answer they were hoping for.
Because my job isn't to tell you what you want to hear. It's to tell you what I genuinely think.
And sometimes, the best property advice is simply:
Don't buy.
Looking for a second opinion on a Dubai property investment? Get in touch through jpdxb.com.